Ƶ

Teacher Shortages: Addressing America’s Education Crisis 

November 25, 2025

Jason Leshowitz

Ed.D. in Leadership

Graphic image of the united states of america

What Is the Teacher Shortage Crisis? 

If you’ve recently tried to hire a certified physics teacher, a bilingual special education teacher or even a seasoned general music instructor, you already know we’re living through the educational version of “The Hunger Games.” Except in this version, there’s no glamorous wardrobe, and the only thing catching fire is your email inbox. The teacher shortage in America isn’t new, but it has reached unprecedented levels. 

This isn’t a temporary setback. It’s a structural crisis driven by policy instability, economic pressures and undervaluing the teaching profession. While headlines often highlight test scores and graduation rates, the real story lies in the erosion of trust, stability and continuity within our schools. 

When classrooms turn into revolving doors, students lose more than instruction. They lose relationships, mentorship and support that drive both academic achievement and emotional development. Our teachers and the students they serve need more support now than ever before, as states continuously call upon the United States Department of Education for help. 

The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics indicates the following to represent the current pulse of the teaching labor market: 

Level of Teaching Job Outlook (projections from 2024-2034) 
Kindergarten and Elementary Teachers  (29,800 job openings) 
Middle School Teachers  (12,400 job openings) 
High School Teachers  (17,800 job openings) 

Thousands of teacher vacancies threaten the next decade of education, as  are either unfilled or filled by those with inadequate teacher certification.  

There is, however, a glimmer of hope. The  found that 45% of American public schools report feeling understaffed for the 2023-24 school year, a decrease from 53% who felt understaffed for the 2022-23 school year. We’re moving in the right direction, but, unfortunately, these things take more time than we prefer. 

Why Certain States Face Greater Challenges 

It’s safe to assume that a list of states with teacher shortages would include all fifty. There are, however, states that face  due to a combination of factors. 

  • Dwindling budgets affecting their ability to offer competitive compensation 
  • Imbalance between the number of teachers leaving and joining the profession 
  • Limited teacher preparation programs 
  • High turnover in certain subject areas 

In New Jersey, where I supervise arts education for a district of over 11,000 students, our proximity to New York City places us in  in the country. Yet starting salaries haven’t kept pace with rent, groceries or basic living expenses. Many promising early-career teachers must choose between staying in the classroom and affording a sustainable life. 

Other regions face different barriers but share the same outcome: 

  • Rural districts struggle to attract candidates. 
  • Urban districts lose teachers faster than they can train them. 

Economic and Social Impact of Teacher Shortages 

This challenge extends far beyond the classroom. It weakens the workforce pipeline, slows economic growth and triggers a ripple effect across entire communities. When schools can’t recruit and retain high-quality teachers: 

  • Class sizes increase. 
  • Support services shrink. 
  • Learning gaps widen. 
  • Graduation rates decline. 
  • Behavioral issues rise. 
  • Academic performance suffers. 

These consequences cascade through local economies, influence future job markets and affect the long-term strength of civic life. Neglecting public education weakens schools and erodes the foundation of society itself. 

The impact is not evenly distributed. Students in high-poverty communities, English learners and those with disabilities often bear the brunt of staffing shortages. When special education teachers are unavailable, these students lose access to the targeted instruction and support that help them succeed. This leads to a widening equity gap that threatens collective progress and reinforces existing disparities. 

States With the Greatest Need for Teachers 

When we assess states with shortages of teachers beyond the average, it’s important to consider the student-teacher ratio. Student enrollment compared to the number of employed teachers illustrates just how dire a state’s shortage is. 

U.S. States With the Greatest Need for Teachers1 
Rank State Ratio* 
Vermont ~ 95 
Maine ~ 87 
New Hampshire ~ 87 
Connecticut ~ 86 
New York ~ 85 
*Ratios are rounded to the nearest whole number. 

Factors Driving Teacher Shortages 

Let’s dive deeper into our top five struggling states and identify potential patterns. 

 

  • Decreased number of teacher preparation program graduates 
  • Lack of competitive teacher pay and benefits, even as one of the top spenders in education 
  • Lack of adequate housing for teachers in rural areas 
  • High cost of childcare for teachers who are also parents 
  • Lack of mentorship and support from more experienced teachers 

 

  • Lack of competitive teacher pay and benefits  
  • Increased resignation rates due to challenging work conditions 
  • School districts with less revenue 

 

  • Lack of competitive teacher pay (one of the lowest in the nation), forcing teachers to take on additional jobs 
  • Decreased student enrollment in teacher preparation programs 

 

  • Continued challenges with student behavioral issues 
  • Lack of competitive teacher pay 
  • Lack of support for the teaching profession 
  • State political shifts that affect education 
  • Increased stress and burnout 

 

  • Decreased enrollment in teacher preparation programs 
  • Increased number of teachers eligible to retire 
  • Increased number of shortage areas throughout the state 

It’s easy to see that the cause of today’s teacher workforce stems from similar root issues. These challenges likely impact school districts across all states in some capacity. The result is a profession that feels less like a calling and more like a battleground. 

Solutions for Addressing Teacher Shortages 

The educational landscape still lives by its mission to value educators and support academic excellence. Here’s where we pivot from crisis to opportunity: 

  • Strategic partnerships with higher education: Build teacher workforce pipelines through partnerships with colleges and universities, like those offered through Ƶ (ACE). 
  • Գǻ: Offer paid, mentored student teaching experiences that prepare candidates for real-world classrooms. 
  • 󲹾dzԲپDz: Move beyond symbolic gestures to meaningful incentives such as loan forgiveness, housing support and competitive salaries. 
  • ٰ𲹳ԱپھپDz: Simplify teacher certification processes without compromising quality. 
  • Leverage technology: Train current teachers with artificial intelligence tools and other processes that can increase efficiency and lighten workloads. 
  • Boost morale: Even small gestures like coffee deliveries can make teachers feel valued. 

FAQs: Teacher Shortage in America 

Why is there a teacher shortage in the United States? 

The teacher shortage crisis stems from a mix of low pay, high stress, inconsistent leadership and declining interest in the profession.

Which states are struggling the most with teacher shortages? 

Vermont, Maine, New Hampshire, Connecticut and New York are struggling the most with teacher shortages. 

How can we solve the teacher shortage problem? 

Pay better. Support more. Respect always. Rethink how we attract, prepare and retain educators. 

What role can communities play?  

Local businesses, universities and civic organizations can partner with schools to offer housing assistance, scholarships and mentorship programs. Community engagement isn’t just helpful, it’s essential. 

Are teacher shortages worse in urban or rural areas? 

Both. Rural areas can’t find candidates, and urban areas can’t keep them. 

Conclusion: Rebuilding the System  

Fixing the teacher shortage isn’t about patching holes in a sinking ship. It’s about rebuilding the vessel with intention, investment and respect. We need: 

  • Long-term funding commitments. 
  • Bold leadership. 
  • A cultural shift that treats teaching as the expert-level profession it is. 

It’s time to stop calling educators heroes while refusing to pay them like professionals. It’s also time to move beyond survival mode and design a system that works. As a district leader, I’ve watched extraordinary teachers walk away—not because they stopped loving the work, but because the work stopped loving them back. 

Let’s turn this ship around – one classroom, one contract and one confident, committed teacher at a time. 

1 

Ƶ offers fully online, affordable education programs that support the career growth of aspiring and current educators. 

Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of Ƶ.
Jason Leshowitz
Jason Leshowitz, Ed.D. in Leadership

Jason Leshowitz is a district supervisor of visual and performing arts for a large urban/suburban school district in northern New Jersey, where he oversees 60 K-12 teachers across music, theater, art, dance, film and television. A devoted husband and father of three, he is currently pursuing an Ed.D. in Leadership. With over three decades of experience in arts education, he is passionate about fostering equitable learning environments and advocating for the role of the arts in student success. In addition to his work as an arts administrator, he enjoys mentoring both new teachers and aspiring administrators and exploring innovative ways to integrate the arts into leadership and curriculum development.

Read all articles
Share this:
Close Chat