Ƶ

In-Person Learning vs. Online Learning: Which Is Right for You? 

October 01, 2025

Brooke McGuire

Ed.D. in Leadership

Woman sitting at a table, watching an instructional video on her laptop while she takes notes in a notebook with a pencil

Schools may have shifted back to in-person instruction, but the COVID-19 pandemic forced educators to re-evaluate. The transition to online classes during the pandemic opened up more possibilities for remote and hybrid learning. 

It’s important to reflect on what worked about online and in-person for yourself and your students’ learning styles — and use that perspective to enhance how we operate. Educators are now equipped with better insight and have an opportunity to move forward with intention.

We examined the pros and cons of online learning and traditional classrooms to help you find the teaching methods and learning styles that work best for you!  

Pros of Traditional Classroom Learning 

Even as online education continues to grow, traditional classroom learning still offers powerful advantages. For many students, a face-to-face experience, structure and a classroom community are critical to academic success: 

  • Real-time feedback: One of the strongest benefits of in-person learning is the ability to interact with teachers and peers in real time. Students can ask questions, get immediate clarification and engage in lively discussions. This direct feedback loop helps students stay engaged and better understand challenging concepts. 
  • Structure and routine: A set schedule can be a huge benefit for students who thrive on routine. Knowing that class starts and ends at specific times helps students manage their day and stay accountable. For younger students, the structured classroom environment provides consistency and reduces distractions. 
  • Hands-on and experiential learning: Certain subjects simply work better in person. Science labs, art studios and performing arts classes all benefit from hands-on practice and physical presence. Students can use equipment, collaborate on group projects and gain practical skills that are harder to replicate in a virtual setting. 
  • Social interaction: Traditional classrooms naturally create opportunities to build relationships with classmates and mentors. A classroom can be a space for younger students to learn teamwork skills or professional networking opportunities for older students. Group projects can lead to friendships and collaboration. These connections often become part of a student’s long-term support system. 
  • Built-in accountability: Having a teacher physically present and classmates nearby helps keep students focused. Attendance policies, deadlines and peer pressure create a built-in system of accountability that encourages participation and timely completion of assignments. 

How Does Online School Work vs. In-Person Learning? 

When looking at online vs. in-person classes, one of the biggest differences is structure. Traditional classrooms follow a fixed daily schedule, with set times for lectures, discussions and group activities. Attendance is mandatory and guided by a teacher in real time, creating a predictable rhythm for students.  

Pacing is also different in each of these environments. In-person learning moves at the pace of the group, which can be helpful for collaboration but challenging for students who learn faster or slower than their peers. Online learning often offers more flexibility, allowing students to pause, rewatch or speed up lessons. This makes it easier to personalize the learning experience, though it does require strong self-motivation and time management skills. 

Finally, class schedule is one of the biggest differences. In-person classes are always synchronous, which means they happen live on a set schedule. Online schools can also be synchronous, requiring students to be online at certain times for things like live instruction or discussions. But it can also be asynchronous, where lessons are pre-recorded and students complete the coursework at their own pace. 

Many online programs combine synchronous and asynchronous components, giving students more control over when they watch lectures, participate in discussions and turn in assignments. 

Image depicting in-person versus online school settings

 Advantages of Online Education 

In some ways, hybrid and distance learning created positive changes, and we can use those lessons to improve classroom instruction. A few pros of online education include: 

  • Learn from anywhere, anytime: We’ve proven that we can be flexible when thinking about what education looks like. It doesn’t mean all kids get the same thing at the same time and in the same way. We can lean into some of what we’ve set up for remote learning to give students more options to learn when it is best for them. Some students are more productive at night. Some may experience an illness requiring them to stay home. Making instructional materials accessible outside the classroom can help students participate even when they can’t physically be in class.  
  • Flexibility: Instead of setting rigid schedules that allot specific times to each subject, how can we be more flexible to better meet student needs? Online courses are flexible and convenient. Plus, giving students a level of control over what they can work on establishes autonomy and develops self-direction. It also allows teachers to give more time to students who need it. 
  • Self-paced options: Online courses can be structured so that students find a rhythm that works for their preferred learning style, working through modules and material at their own pace. This also makes online classes ideal for adult students who may also be balancing work and family obligations. 
  • Cost-effective higher education: Maybe you’re career-prepping seniors for higher education and life beyond graduation, or maybe you’re ready to go back to school yourself for a ٱ’s or doctorate. Whatever the reason, when considering options for online vs. in-person colleges, it’s important to keep in mind that online courses often mean lower tuition. With no commute or housing costs, the overall price tag of a college degree shrinks substantially. 
  • Equity and inclusivity: We cannot lose sight of the equity concerns that were raised when the learning environment moved online in 2020. While that shift may have expedited one-to-one initiatives or raised awareness about the lack of internet access, inequitable education still exists, and should be top of mind as we plan ahead. Along with flexible schedules, what if we could always ensure that students have a distance learning option? Some students may have health concerns or other unique situations that make remote learning ideal for them. Continuing to provide distance learning meets the needs of students and helps them become independent learners. Online tools also provide the flexibility to accommodate individualized learning styles and diverse learning needs through the use of accessible learning tools like closed captions and recordings. Prioritizing professional development in culturally-responsive pedagogy and anti-bias education, reviewing assessment practices, including diverse perspectives in your curriculum, and using technology tools — these are all ways to deepen your commitment to equity. 

Online Learning Drawbacks 

While online learning offers flexibility and accessibility, it’s not without its challenges. You’re probably already intimately familiar with them, especially if you’re an educator who survived an online transition in 2020. But if you’re a new teacher or prospective student, understanding the potential drawbacks can help you prepare and decide whether virtual education is the right fit. 

  • Limited interaction: One of the most common concerns about online school is the lack of face-to-face social interaction. Your students will definitely miss the casual conversations, group activities and peer relationships that naturally form in a traditional classroom (even if they don’t want to admit it). This can be especially difficult for younger or extroverted students who thrive on collaboration and real-time discussion. Some programs attempt to address this with virtual clubs, group projects and live discussion forums, but the experience is often different from in-person community building. 
  • Self-discipline: Online learning gives students more freedom, but that freedom can be a double-edged sword. Without a teacher physically present to keep them on task, some students struggle to stay motivated, manage their time and complete assignments on schedule — especially in asynchronous courses where there’s less direct accountability. Students who excel in self-directed environments tend to thrive, but those who need external structure may find it difficult to stay engaged. 
  • Barriers to technology: Reliable technology is essential for online learning. Students need access to a computer or tablet, a stable internet connection and sometimes specific software. Technical issues — like slow internet speeds, outdated devices or platform glitches — can disrupt learning and cause frustration. Additionally, students who aren’t tech-savvy may face a steep learning curve just figuring out how to navigate online platforms. 
  • Limited hands-on learning opportunities: If your subject relies on labs, hands-on practice or physical demonstration, it can be difficult to replicate this experience for online students. While simulations and virtual labs exist, they often can’t fully replace the experience of working with real materials, equipment or instruments. This limitation can affect fields like science, healthcare and performing arts. 
  • Delayed communication and feedback: In a physical classroom, students can ask questions and get immediate answers. In online courses, communication may take longer — especially if instructors are balancing many students across different time zones. Delayed feedback on assignments can slow progress and leave students unsure whether they’re on the right track. 
Image listing pros and cons for online learning

Blending the Best of Both Worlds 

For educators, there are lots of easy ways to integrate the best aspects of both in-person and online learning modalities. At the core of each are the 3 Cs: 

  • Collaboration: While social interaction is important, effective communication can take many different forms. Even if you’re running a fully in-person classroom, consider still incorporating online discussions and video conferencing alongside the usual in-person meetings. Some students are more likely to participate in discussions, whether in-person or virtual, when they have more think time or the option to contribute in writing instead of verbally. 
  • Connections: We can still take advantage of things like virtual field trips, Zoom calls and pen pals to help students learn from and make connections with people and experts all over the world. And teachers can as well. It’s never been easier to connect with professional peers, which can be especially helpful for content teachers in smaller districts who may often feel like they are working in isolation.  
  • Courses: Push those collaborations and professional connections even further: Are you able to provide courses to students from other districts or offer courses jointly? Can you work with other districts or online educators to add to the courses offered? Working together increases opportunities for students and districts alike. 

Choosing the Right Learning Path 

Both in-person and online learning have unique strengths, and the best choice depends on each individual student’s goals and circumstances. Traditional classrooms offer structure, hands-on experiences and face-to-face connections that help students stay engaged and accountable, while online courses provide flexibility and opportunities for personalized pacing. By understanding the benefits and challenges of each format, students and educators can make informed decisions that maximize learning outcomes. Whether you choose a physical classroom, a virtual one or a blend of both, the key is finding an approach that supports meaningful collaboration, connection and growth. 

Ƶ’s fully online, flexible programs can equip educators with effective instructional strategies for both in-person and online educational settings. Explore our education programs today. 

Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of Ƶ.
Brooke McGuire
Brooke McGuire, Ed.D. in Leadership

Brooke has taught in a variety of settings, working everything from a service-learning summer program geared toward incoming first graders to a high school program for struggling readers. She's currently the director of teaching and learning at her district.

Read all articles
Share this:
Close Chat